Speak to a member of the Mermaids team. 08088010400 Web chat

News

Mermaids Press

Content warning: transphobia, trans suicide

Allison (she/her), a member of Mermaids’ Youth Advisory Panel, breaks down the real, harmful impacts that new schools’ guidance will have on trans young people.

In September 2026, the latest version of the Department for Education’s ‘Keeping Children Safe in Education’ guidance, or KCSIE for short, came into effect. This is statutory guidance, so all schools and colleges in England must apply it unless they can prove they have a strong reason not to do so.

The introduction of this new schools’ guidance is devastating for our community, as it outright bans trans and gender diverse children and young people from using the toilets and changing facilities that match their gender identity.

It also creates significant barriers to socially transitioning in schools and creates many opportunities for trans children and young people to be outed, exposing them to risks of bullying. Trans children and young people will effectively be segregated from their peers and discouraged from transitioning at every step possible.

Photo of Allison in protect trans youth t shirt, arms crossed

Segregating trans children and young people

The “debate” about access to bathrooms and changing facilities is now all too common in the UK, with trans-exclusionary policies now the standard, as is the case with this new guidance. However, the impact that this will have on trans+ children in schools should not be understated. The social effects of segregating children in this way should be clear: it will result in people being outed as trans to members of their peer group who may well be unaware that they had previously transitioned. This carries significant risks of transphobic bullying and abuse, which will have adverse effects on the mental health of an already vulnerable group.

Practically, many schools will not have designated gender-neutral toilets for students in every building. In some cases, trans young people may use accessible toilets as a substitute, which will reduce their availability for the disabled people who need them. The guidance does not require schools to provide alternative facilities, and that instead they “should consider whether they can provide” them, which means trans children and young people have no guarantee of safe access to a bathroom at school. 

The guidance also suggests that gendered sports could be segregated for reasons of “fairness” and must be where there is a “need to ensure children’s safety”. This prevents children from playing with their peers and feeds into the transphobic narrative of trans people, particularly trans women, creating an unfair and unsafe environment in sport. This is despite recent research (Mendes Sieczkowska et al., 2026) finding that the scientific evidence does not support this. Changing rooms are treated the same as toilets, where again the guidance says students must not use facilities matching their gender identity, and schools “should consider” providing alternative provision for trans children and young people. The wording of this means there is no legal requirement to provide them, or to even consider a request if the school considers there to be a “good reason not to”. This will leave many trans young people without suitable facilities. The same exclusionary approach applies to overnight accommodation.

Removing trans children and young people’s agency

The guidance notably does not use the terms trans or transgender to refer to trans and gender diverse young people, instead opting to refer to them as “gender questioning”. The use of this term implies that trans children and young people are unsure about their identity, or do not have the agency to be able to self-identify. This is patronising and dehumanising language and is clearly an intentional choice from the Department for Education. 

By refusing to refer to people as transgender, it illegitimises our community’s own identity and vocabulary.

More concerningly, the guidance aligns itself with the Cass Review (of NHS gender services, which makes no reference to education) to formulate a position on social transition, suggesting that “for the majority [of children questioning their gender] this will not continue into adulthood”. This position de-centres and puts down young peoples’ own lived experiences to support a harmful anti-trans narrative. It requires senior staff, along with the child’s parents, to decide whether a child is allowed to socially transition. For young people in schools, a social transition might include different clothing, and a new haircut, as well as asking people to use a different name and pronouns.

The guidance states that “a decision relating to social transition may not be the same as a child’s wishes”. This makes it entirely defensible for a school to prevent a child from socially transitioning, which could have devastating effects on their mental health.

This situation reminds me of some of my own experiences from when I was in a boys’ secondary school. A decision was made by school staff and my parents that it would be “better for me academically” to remain at that school and socially transition there, rather than let me move to a mixed gender school, until after my GCSEs which were 18 months away.

The feelings of being trapped and having my agency taken away from me have stuck with me since then and resulted in major mental health issues which have taken many years to improve, and still not fully resolved.

I can’t even imagine how devastating it would be for a young person to reach out for support and be told that what they want is wrong and can’t be permitted. How many children will choose to suffer in silence instead of facing that possibility? 

Additionally, the guidance recommends that decisions on whether children and young people should socially transition should be reviewed by school staff where it has “placed an unsustainable pressure on school resources”, or where it has become apparent that someone has been living in stealth (living their correct gender identity without being publicly trans). Theoretically, this could lead to a school deciding to publicly out someone to their friends and teachers. When I moved schools for sixth form, I was stealth to everyone but my close friends, and this would have been a terrifying scenario for me.

All I’ve ever wanted is to just live my life and fit in, and it feels like this guidance is going to make trans kids stand out and create huge barriers to taking part in everyday activities.

If you are another young trans person reading this, I want you to know you are not alone. We are living through scary times, and I don’t want to sugarcoat that, and so your own wellbeing should always be the number one priority. Know that there are people out there fighting for our rights, and there is support available.

Mermaids’ Support Line is here to lend a listening ear, via the phone, webchat and email. Head to their webpage for more information, including opening hours.

Neglecting trans children and young people’s wellbeing

The KCSIE guidance will also reduce teachers’ abilities to support trans kids, with them not being permitted to “adopt any changes relating to social transition”, such as using the correct name and pronouns for a child or young person, without this decision being permitted by senior staff. It reinforces the current legal position that “gender critical beliefs”, also known as transphobia, is a protected belief and that this should be considered in the context of sanctioning any bullying or harassment.

In the 7-page long section on “gender questioning children”, there is no guidance on how to ensure trans and gender diverse young peoples’ wellbeing is supported, something which should be of extreme concern given that a recent investigation found that trans young people made up a disproportionate 7% of the all child suicides from 2019-2025, despite only being 1% of the general population (McCool and Parsons, 2026).

The KCSIE guidance feels deliberately designed to dehumanise and delegitimise trans children and young people by questioning their agency at every step.

Allison, wearing a shirt that reads “NOTHING ABOUT US WITHOUT US”, at London Trans Pride 2026

The choice to describe trans young people as “gender questioning” denies their own lived experience, personhood and autonomy. Young people should be the ones at the centre of their own worlds, not parents or school staff.

This guidance will leave young people feeling powerless and trapped and puts schools and teachers in a conflicting and unsustainable legal and moral position. 

This harm is preventable. The Government must act to amend the Equality Act 2010 and ensure that the law correctly protects trans people from gender-based discrimination, before updating the many policies and guidance papers issued since the April 2025 Supreme Court judgement.

Until that happens, my call to decision makers and youth workers at every level is to ensure that young people’s voices are heard, in all decisions that affect them.

About the author

Allison (she/her) is a member of Mermaids’ Youth Advisory Panel. She has worked as a welfare officer and designated safeguarding lead at holiday activity camps for children aged 6-11.